| 
           
          We propose that Dato' Seri Abdullah 
          Ahmad Badawi create a breath of fresh air for the media so that 
          Malaysians can enjoy more enlightened and balanced news and views 
  
           
 
          Press Statement 
          by Dr Tan Seng Giaw 
    (Kuala Lumpur, Tuesday): 
          
          
     Dato' Seri Abdullah insists that Malaysia practises parliamentary 
    democracy. One of the bases of this system is freedom of the media (not the 
    freedom to harm the society). Just as Dato' Seri Dr Mahathir, Pak Lah 
    believes that international media can be very biased. Then, he should look 
    into the state of our media. 
     
     We would like the world media to be open and just. Whether it is CNN, BBC, 
    the New York Times, The Washington Post, The Sydney Morning Herald, The 
    Times or the Guardian, UK, Le Figaro and so forth, we expect them to be fair 
    and just. Similarly, we hope Malaysian media move towards this direction. 
     
     What does Pak Lah think of the Malaysian media? Does he feel that they are 
    prejudiced or jaundiced? As the Home Minister, his view on the desire of 
    Chin Peng, the former Secretary-General of the Communist Party of Malaya (CPM) 
    to return home from southern Thailand has been headlined. For one reason or 
    another, the Government refuses Chin Peng's request. On 7 October, 2003, the 
    Deputy Prime Minister said that Chin Peng had links with terrorist 
    organizations in the country and that there was nothing more to say on the 
    matter. 
     
     Those who want to know alternative views have to access the Internet. For 
    example, some people such as Lim Kit Siang think that the Government should 
    consider letting him come home. The Parit Sulong MP Ruhanie quoted 
    Malaysiakini on Kit Siang's view.  
     Yesterday, there was a heated debate on the issue in Parliament. But, 
    today some newspapers carry a small column on the issue and some don't, let 
    alone on meaningful debate. Surely, the public would like to know whether 
    Chin Peng is still linked to terrorist organizations. Why has the Government 
    allowed some ex-CPM leaders such as Abdullah Ahmad to return but not the 
    others? Why was the late Ahmad Zaidi Addruse, who was a Communist 
    underground, permitted to become a Sarawak minister and governor? Would Chin 
    Peng's return evoke uncontrollable emotions among victims of CPM? Has Chin 
    Peng any contribution against the Japanese in the Second World War and the 
    withdrawal of the British from Malaya in 1957? 
     
     Malaysians would like balanced views on all aspects including politics, 
    economy, trade, finance, education, religions and cultures. Malaysian press 
    should be fair even if international may not be. 
     
     There have always been glowing reports on many things in Malaysia. The 
    economy is reported as doing better than what it actually is. Putrajaya is 
    simply the best administrative capital. True, we need such a centre. But, 
    the expenditure of various projects in the centre requires enquiry. Are they 
    value for money? 
     
     Those who have opportunities seek alternative views and news. As the 
    Government spends over 20% of the national budget on education, more 
    Malaysians will be educated. As more people are educated, they will hunger 
    for balanced views and news. The number of Internet users will increase 
    steadily. 
     
     Dato' Seri Abdullah should consider giving the media a breath of fresh air. 
    If he can truly do this, then the openness would require responsibility and 
    ethics. 
  
    
          (28/10/2003) 
           
     
    *  Dr 
    Tan Seng Giaw, DAP National Vice Chairman & MP for Kepong 
           
      
     |