Skip to content

Anifah said so much yet answered so little

I would like to thank Foreign Minister Dato Sri Anifah Aman for his quick response to my media statement yesterday pertaining to Malaysia’s failure to get elected to the United Nation’s Human Rights Council.

Although I had asked him to provide the reply in the Parliament, he had decided to provide it immediately after I issued my statement. Unfortunately, despite his long reply, he didn’t say much, and when he did, they were mostly excuses instead of real answers.

The Minister did not tell us why we lost our bid for the UN HRC seat, why Malaysia was rejected by member countries and how much we had spent to lobby for the seat that we lost.

In my statement, all I did was to say that “I will be submitting a Parliamentary Question for Minister’s Question Time on Tuesday 24th October 2017 to give Foreign Minister Anifah Aman the first available opportunity to explain why Malaysia failed in its bid to be elected to the United Nations Human Rights Council”.

I also added that “It is shocking that Malaysia failed in its diplomatic effort and Parliament deserves to know what had happened”.

Instead, the Minister was being condescending towards my statement, alleging that my question had “a sinister hope” that “Malaysia’s unsuccessful bid has and will taint the country’s reputation and image in the international fora.”

The Minister must explain what he means by “not to be myopic in our vision” as mentioned in his statement, especially when Malaysia’s Permanent Mission to United Nations in January this year had announced the Government of Malaysia’s pledges and commitments if elected to the HRC. Did we fail because member countries rejected our pledges and commitments? Or were there more than meets the eye? Is it because Malaysia’s reputation has been tarnished by Prime Minister Najib Razak’s global scandals?

On Anifah’s statement that “we can use our friends who are now on board of the Council such as Afghanistan, Nepal, Qatar and the others”, I would like to ask that, wouldn’t it make more sense that if Malaysia were to “use our friends”, we shouldn’t have competed in the election in the first place? As mentioned, none of the other groups had competition except the Asia Pacific Group.

The Minister gave several possible reasons for Malaysia’s failed bid:

  1. Member states backing a first-time candidate – again, if we knew this why did weh compete?
  2. Early submission of the candidature – Did we make a late submission? From what I gathered, Malaysia submitted in January, which was not late at all.
  3. The ability to campaign aggressively due to unlimited financial resources – what are we trying to imply here; that other countries have used a lot of money? Or that we failed to match them in terms of money spent for the campaign? Or we didn’t use money?

What does the Minister mean when he said “the Ministry was extremely frugal during its lobbying efforts”; how much money was spent and how was the campaign conducted? This is important because it involves taxpayers’ money.

I still hope the Minister will not shy away from replying in the Parliament next week, and provide real answers instead of excuses. I hope Parliament Speaker Tan Sri Pandikar Amin would allow my Minister’s Question Time to Anifah to be on the agenda or alternatively, Anifah could table a Ministerial Statement to Parliament to explain this major diplomatic failure which requires more answers than what he had provided as yet.