Let me tell you a story. In October last year, I door stopped the Selangor Menteri Besar, Azmin Ali, in Parliament and spoke to him about a program that could uplift the socio-economic status of poor Indians in the state.
My idea was to create an enabling environment for them through a series of skills training workshops.
It was the easiest conversation I have ever had as Azmin approved of the idea instantly and pumped in an initial fund of one million ringgit to support the program.
A series of workshops – tailoring, baking, digital marketing, photography, graphic design and the making of traditional cookies were started this year, training 240 participants.
The second phase, which started two days back, would train another 150 poor Indians in nail art, manicure and pedicure, bridal, e-commerce, tailoring and pastry-making.
And all 420 participants would have access to interest-free Hijrah loans as well to kick-start their businesses.
This is a public-public partnership by a government that is committed to uplifting poor Indians and providing them with equal opportunities to complement existing family incomes.
In direct contrast, Najib’s budget comes with more stimulus programmes to boost growth and is aimed at shoring up support ahead of the general election – in short an election budget.
Najib’s budget allocates 50 million ringgit for entrepreneurship, another 50 million ringgit for socio economic development, some 1.5 billion ringgit as investment fund and a seven-percent intake in government jobs and public universities.
While the Indian entrepreneurship program rings pleasant, the government has to show tangible results as to how many have benefited from previous allocations.
The other 50 million ringgit allocation is from the Socio Economic Development of the Indian Community (SEDIC).
Firstly, SEDIC has to show how past allocations have resulted in enabling Indians who fall under the Bottom 40 (B40) category.
This has not been done despite me harping about it in Parliament over the last few years.
Najib must also explain as to why the money for SEDIC has been reduced over the years, from 80 million ringgit to 50 million for 2018.
And the irony is that the 1.5 billion ringgit investment scheme would only benefit middle-class Indians, as they are the ones with the money to invest.
I have another story to share. Three months ago I organised a program to look at Indian poverty in Petaling Jaya.
There, I proposed a seven-percent intake in government jobs and public universities. And voila, the government copies that idea for its Budget 2018.
In reality, this has been the demand of the Indian community and it has taken the UMNO-led Barisan Nasional government ten to fifteen years to make it happen. If anything, this is a victory to the people.
The self-styled champions of the Indian community, the Malaysian Indian Congress (MIC), couldn’t represent the aspirations of the community because of the client-patron relationship enjoyed with big boss UMNO.
Dr S Subramaniam, the current MIC chief, should therefore not blow the party’s trumpet or glorify the government for the budget as similar allocations over years hasn’t pushed the poor Indians towards an upward mobility.
The key to a successful budget lies in its implementation. The Selangor government’s program, in direct contrast, could clearly show how Indian women and men have benefitted.
Days before Najib unveiled the budget Pakatan Harapan announced its shadow budget where, to tackle the dismal entrepreneurship participation of Malaysian Indians, it would set aside two billion ringgit to give out 4% interest rate loan scheme to those eligible.
It would also set up a special economic empowerment fund to increase the equity share of Indians, which remain at a low of 1.5%-1.6%.
To ensure the next generation of Indians have a fair shot at life, Pakatan Harapan’s policies would include a revamp of welfare payments and the introduction of a conditional cash transfer program.
It would also create a special Single Parent’s Welfare program where Indians in the B40 category earning less than 2000 ringgit a month could receive 100 ringgit per month per child, to help them support and nurture their children.
These programs are tailored after the Bolsa Familia program in Brazil, which attempts to both reduce short-term and fight long-term poverty by increasing human capital among the poor.
It’s clear that a strong political will and sustained financing are crucial to alleviate the sufferings of poor Indians in this country.
The fact that they remain destitute after six decades of policies and budget allocations by the ruling government is very telling.
For just as former US President Franklin Roosevelt said “The test of our progress is not whether we add more to the abundance of those who have much; it is whether we provide enough for those who have too little.”