Skip to content

Cameron Highlands needs a global solution rather than a piecemeal, ad hoc and temporary solution

We appreciate the attention the Regent of Pahang Tengku Abdullah Sultan Ahmad Shah is giving to the problems of the people of Cameron Highlands when he commented on the labour shortage in Cameron Highlands. This is our response to a news coverage on The Star titled “Regent: Address Cameron Highland Labour shortage” on 30 September 2017.

He commented that Cameron Highlands is facing a serious problem of a foreign labour shortage in the farming and plantation sectors. Quoting him, “We must understand Cameron Highlands is a high quality vegetable and fruit producing area. Imagine the losses incurred if we don’t have manpower” we agree that this is a serious problem faced by farmers and agricultural stakeholders in Cameron Highlands.

This is an economic problem and therefore good governance is of utmost importance. The problems in Cameron Highlands is essentially one that was encouraged by the government both State Government as well as Federal. Years of corruption and using power to profit from farmers have led to the current scenario of land encroachments and the use of illegal foreign labour.

I have received complaints from farmers that they were bullied into paying sums of money for use of lands and yet their farms were broken down during Ops Gading. Why tacitly allow the use of land and then sweep in with an operation like Ops Gading which involved 16 government agencies? Was it the government’s intention to scare the people? The mannerism in which these farms were broken down also raises doubts on the intention of the government. The government agencies knew of these farms and farmers all these years and have been profiting from these farms directly or indirectly.

At this point I would also like to state that foreign workers policy by the government is laughable. The government allows illegal foreign workers to come into the country, the government allows them to work and then government agencies sweep in with aggressive force in operations like Ops Gading to have them all arrested. It’s almost like a joke. The same entity who allows any amount of undocumented foreign workers to enter the country is also the same entity that arrests them and claims to be a hero.

I have several questions to raise on behalf of affected farmers in Cameron Highlands. If the government acknowledges that there is a need for foreign labourers, why not have a proper foreign workers intake policy to benefit the farmers? Also why are farm lands in Cameron Highlands on a perpetual TOL basis when many farmers have been operating their farms for more than 20-30 years. Why can’t these lands be leased to them on a fixed term basis? The government is profiting abundantly from renewals of TOL licenses, how is this revenue put back to serve the people of Cameron Highlands?

Why are more TOL land given out when the existing ones cannot be managed properly? Are these TOL land given to outsiders?

Besides lack of workers or foreign workers on the farms in Cameron Highlands, there are numerous other problems like flooding, hillslope erosion (the Tapah road that leads up to Cameron Highlands is a time bomb waiting for a major landslide), water contamination as chemical fertilisers are seeping into the water table, traffic jams where it takes more than an hour from Kea farm to Tanah Rata, over use of plastic sheets in the farms are matters of major concern.

The other question is why the overdependence on foreign workers? Why not the government give subsidies or incentives to the farmers if they employ locals, if they use less plastic, use proper rubbish disposal methods, use organic fertilisers etc etc.

Cameron Highlands needs a global solution rather than a piecemeal, ad hoc and temporary solution. Tackle corruption. The land office in Cameron Highlands is notoriously known for extorting high amount of payments from farmers to process any procedural applications.

Now we feel the real objective of Ops Gading is not to help the farmers and people of Cameron Highlands but to instil fear amongst them that the authorities can and will take action to punish and hurt them in certain circumstances whenever it suits the authorities.