Skip to content

Debate by SA for Bukit Assek, Irene Mary Chang Oi Ling on Sarawak Multimedia Authority Bill 2017

Tuan Speaker, I rise to participate in the debate on the Sarawak Multimedia Authority Bill, 2017. It is noted that this Bill is much more comprehensive than its predecessor, the Sarawak Information Technology and Resources Council Ordinance 1999 (Cap 28). This is to be expected given the vast advancement in the role of multimedia in today’s society. Digital technology has made its inroad into almost every sector of the international arena. And it is therefore commendable that Sarawak is trying to keep abreast with digital technology to further enhance our commitment and involvement to allow Sarawak to be able to compete in the national as well as in international platform. Per se, I support the intention of the Bill. However, I wish to raise the following issues in relation to the Bill.

1. Government Bills

Tuan Speaker, we always say, charity starts in our own home. In everything that we want to do outside our homes, we should make sure that we are already practising it in our own homes. Similarly, I wish to say that the initiative the make Sarawak a cyber powerhouse, should also start with this August House first before we can convince the people of Sarawak to embrace digital technology. I refer to the Government Bills, the soft copies of which were only extended to some of us, the opposition members outside Kuching, one day before the sitting in this August house starts. Tuan Speaker, I only received mine yesterday morning when I was in the middle of my preparation to fly to Kuching. And truth be told, Tuan Speaker, this limits the time for us to study the Bills thoroughly and carefully before we can decide to support or oppose the Bill with proper grounds. Tuan Speaker, we owe it to the people of Sarawak that all members in this August House should come properly prepared for all matters which is going to be raised in this House and it is indeed a crying shame if we cannot practice what we preach in putting to good use the cyber laws we are seeking to put in place.

2. Freedom of Information Bill

Clause 19 of the Bill enacts something which was not in the predecessor Ordinance. That is, the right to investment of moneys which was not immediately required to be expended in the meeting of any obligations or the discharge of any functions of the Authority. It makes good business sense to put unused money to good use to earn more money for the use of the Authority. But a possible loophole in the Bill is that there is nothing in the Bill which provides that the money earned from the investment should go back to the Fund established under Clause 17). Furthermore, the Bill says nothing on providing information on the investments made.

Again, with the desire to fully achieve the information era, governments should be open and transparent in their undertakings. And towards that end, I propose that it is time that Sarawak should also embark on to be the first of the BN governments to enact the Freedom of Information Bill. A government that has nothing to hide should not be afraid of scrutiny by the public. This would also promote transparency and accountability which would help to minimise instances of corruption.

3. Sarawak Pay

Tuan Speaker, it cannot be denied that a cashless society is the way of the future. Governments around the world want to desperately latch on to and realise the benefits such as efficiency and convenience which a cashless society can provide. The benefits, no doubt, are aplenty, especially after listening to the success story of Estonia by our Right Honourable Chief Minister in his budget speech. And it’s therefore good that our Sarawak government wants to hop on to the wagon.

However, Tuan Speaker, in the interest of the people, I need to express my concern that nothing much has been revealed about the mechanism of this newest proposed Electronic Bill Payment engine. We only know that we have the approval of Bank Negara to go cashless by 2018 and that the digital payment system is a collaboration between our state government and the Chinese multinational company, Huawei. And we have been informed that the state government would gently ease us into the cashless society by using it for payment of all local government services.

Tuan Speaker, here are some of the people’s concern. The people is anxious to know the arrangement of the proposed Joint Venture between the state government and Huawei Company. What is the costs of installing the digital payment system? Who bears them? Are these costs allocated on a “user pays” basis? Would the people incur service charge for the use of the system and who would be collecting these service charges, Huawei or our state government? Furthermore, in what way is the mechanism for Sarawak Pay different from our current Electronic Bill Presentment and Payment engine in PayBillsMalaysia and PayBillsSarawak which is already available for online payment for local government agencies and participating merchants?

Of paramount importance, is the security issue. A google in internet would reveal that Huawei’s economic expansion into markets in regions of Africa, Asia, Canada and New Zealand has already achieved much success. However, Huawei is considered a threat to national cyber security by many foreign governments which includes Singapore, Australia, United States and India. These countries are still resisting the infiltration of Huawei’s technologies into their national infrastructure. And what is of particular concern is the speculation that Huawei is owned by the Chinese government. We don’t know if this is true or untrue as we can not discount the possibility that the speculation might be prompted by international business rivalry. Be that as it may, our state government owes it to the people to walk very cautiously before full commitment. This is especially when we are ahead of the Federal Government and therefore there might not be any system or apps in place yet to guard the personal data of those who utilize the payment system.

Tuan Speaker, there are already too many cyber scams even with the security safeguards in place. What more to say, with no security safeguards in place yet as this would be the first of its kind in Malaysia. We might seriously be compromising on the safety of the personal data of our people or even worse, even on the data of our government agencies as we are building our payment infrastructure on the digital system which might be operated by an international foreign country, of course depending on what arrangement has been reached between our state govt and Huawei. And if we proceed without any special attention to the international speculation concerning Huawei, there is a possibility that one day, we might find all our personal data and government data in the hands of the Chinese government. I urge the state government to tread carefully and do a due diligence exercise on Huawei first before full commitment. With the desire to keep abreast with the technology world comes the heavy responsibility of safeguarding our government and people from cyber theft of our government and personal data.

I urge the government to consider the considerations I put forward here.

With these remarks, I conclude.