Skip to content

Inextricable relationship between ideology and good governance

My piece “There is no system of governance without ideology” (FMT, 20 Nov) elicited a few comments in the letters to editor column.

TK Chua replied that it is true that no system of government is free of ideology but surely there should not be a blind pursuit of ideological concerns without giving importance to good governance, pragmatism, corruption- free government, sound principles and ethics.

I totally agree with Chua on the need of these for any system of government, whether it is socialist or capitalist.

In fact, I would agree that these are the minimal prerequisites for any political system to take off.

I always enjoyed the articles written by Chua.

Among the many contributors, I find his analysis sharp and to the point. He is not the type who argues in circles.

Actually, I have no fundamental disagreement with Chua.

It more the question of nuances and emphasis. In fact, a full-fledged discourse on ideologies and their relationship to good governance can be a lengthy one.

Yes, I am all for a good political system whatever it is called but the ideological underpinnings cannot dismissed.

I am for good governance, pragmatism, sound ethics and principles, a corruption free government where the divide between the poor and rich are eventually bridged in economic, political and social terms.

There is no point for having a “great” socialist government when some fundamental questions of good governance are not addressed.

Similarly what is the point of having a “good” capitalist system devoid of principles of good governance?

There is no point in blindly focusing on ideology of a political system without measuring its concrete performance in terms of good governance.

The test is not ideology but whether such an ideology can bring about the maximum happiness or contentment.

It is not that we should forsake ideology. Even if we forsake ideology, no human being is free of ideology.

Whether we are politicians or decision makers, our thoughts and decisions are derived from the numerous influences that have impacted our lives and how we see the world.

Singapore is good example of country that followed the dictates of neoliberal ideology to the tilt, but it nonetheless did not side step issue of good governance.

This is the central point of Chua. I concur!

This would perhaps explain why the system continues to be relevant but at the same time we cannot ignore that clouds of dissent are also gathering.

Not because there is no good governance, perhaps there is too much of “guiding” that has affected the freedom of younger generation of Singaporeans.

It would be wrong to assume that we are caught in a straightjacket of having to contend with a few ideological beliefs.

It must be realized even within a certain ideology that there are so many variants that sometimes these variants appear to be diametrical opposite each other.

In Malaysia, the differences between BN and PH are to be sought in the realm of good governance.

It is not so much the ideological debate that rages on between the adherents of both the coalitions, but rather the question of bringing about political and social change.

In this respect, since BN has failed, PH wants to step to address the issue by taking on the former in the coming general election.

PSM also believes in socialism but the not the revolutionary version, but one that thinks that the capitalism system can be reformed through parliamentary means.

How a political system ensures good governance is an important consideration in the present debate.

Although I am agreeable that the issue of good governance cannot be sidestepped, I still believe that there is an inextricable relationship between it and ideology.

In fact, I would argue that it is the profound belief in a set of ideas (constitutes ideology) that provides the basis for good governance.

Ideology and good governance are inextricably related to one another.