Nothing could be more demeaning to the Indian community then to say that Indian intake into public universities has been increased due to the imposition of an ethnic quota.
In other words, since Indians are not qualified academically to gain admission to institutions of higher learning, they need some kind of an affirmative policy action.
While Malay and Chinese students gain admission to institutions of higher learning based on their academic performance, Indian students, due to their dismal performance, needs to governmental crutch in terms of preferential treatment to ensure a sizeable intake.
Najib Tun Razak, in his recent address at the Indian Progressive Front’s 25th AGM, said that he had no choice but to abandon the meritocracy policy of admission of students into institutions of higher learning insofar as the Indians are concerned.
Mahathir Mohammed introduced the meritocracy policy during his tenure as the prime minister to bring about competition amongst Malay students. Such a policy inadvertently created problems for Indians students for entry into institutions of higher learning.
According to Najib, if the government had maintained the meritocracy policy, it would mean that Indian students admitted to institutions of higher learning would be around 3.4 percent and not 7 percent.
He said that the Indian community needed assistance and this could not be brought about with the continuation of the meritocracy policy. For the long-term interest of the Indian community, he had no choice but to abandon this policy to provide for more intakes of Indian students in the matriculation programme and entry into public universities.
A policy of ethnic quota for Indians has meant that 1500 places have been accorded for Indian students in matriculation programme and 700 extra spots for Indians in public universities.
A policy need not be abandoned just because there is need to make some exceptions for some reasons. On this matter, it would be wrong for Najib to say that he had discontinued Mahathir’s policy of meritocracy.
However, in his speech, he was not sure whether the meritocracy policy as a whole has been abandoned or some exceptions have been made to accommodate the interests of the Indian community.
I think that the latter is true.
Yes, some exceptions have been made to increase Indian intake into institutions of higher learning, but the race-based policy or pro-Malay policy to advance the interests of Malays in employment and intake into institutions of higher learning continues unabated.
Meritocracy is there, but it is subordinated to Umno’s Malay agenda.
If Najib had indeed abandoned the meritocracy policy of Mahathir, it would have meant not only the slow but sure reduction of Malay employment in the public sector but also in terms of admission into institutions of higher learning.
From the time of the New Economic Policy and until today, there is no such thing as a meritocracy policy that was subscribed by the government with Umno in the commanding heights. It has always been an ethnic or pro-Malay policy with different degrees of meritocracy.
Meritocracy was always there as long such an emphasis did not interfere or disrupt the larger Malay agenda of Malay dominance.
Tampering with Malay agenda would have rendered Umno extremely unpopular with the Malays. In fact, it would be a truism to state that the party would have lost in the elections, if the Malay agenda were abandoned.
The argument that meritocracy policy was introduced amongst Malays but was set aside for the progress of the Indian community is a complete nonsense to say the least. By saying this, Najib is once again ridiculing the efforts of the Indian community for all its hard work and perseverance.
The whole country knows that without a race-based policy, Malays would not have attained dominance in the public sector or in terms of intake or employment in the institutions of higher learning.
Just because extra places have been accorded for Indian students in public universities or in the matriculation programmes, does not spell the death of race-based policy in Malaysia.
Sorry, race-based Malay agenda is the life-blood of Umno, without it the party would disintegrate!