Skip to content

New Deal is not personal agenda, it’s about Institutional Reform

Deputy Chief Minister of Sabah, Datuk Seri Raymond Tan, has adopted a bias approach in reading Pakatan Harapan Sabah New Deal manifesto. He tried in every means in distorting and twisting the noble intention of the New Deal to “an excuse to remove the Special Rights of Sabah and Sarawak”. He even accused “Mahathir and PH leaders still have plans to remove our immigration rights”.

He said, “most of us do not ask for anything more but we want to protect our Special Rights” and “nobody in Sabah, in his right mind, would be interested to renegotiate a new deal with Mahathir or PH”.

We PH Sabah strongly condemn his unfounded wild allegations against the New Deal, and we feel deeply regret about Raymond’s bad attitude by not respecting a senior stateman, Tun Mahathir. This should not be a gentleman’s attitude, even though we are different in political views.

While PH Sabah agrees that we must defend all Sabah’s Special Rights and safeguards under the Malaysia Agreement 1963 (“MA63”; whenever mentioned, shall include the Inter-Governmental Committee Report, “IGCR”), we also believe that MA63 should be regarded only as our bottom line, not our final goal. In other words, PH Sabah believe that Sabah can do better than as envisaged under MA63, without denying the sanctity of MA63 in any way.

After more than 5 decades of Malaysia experience for Sabah, it is the time for us to take a bold and imaginative approach in foring the destiny of Sabah. The bold and imaginative way is, what we call as New Deal.

New Deal, is a deal for Sabah to renegotiate with, in achieving real and meaningful autonomy, which which gives us the pertinent power, capacities and resources to govern ourselves and to shape our own destiny, and not just autonomy in the narrow sense of “not having to take orders from Malaya”.

For example, under MA63, the main legislative jurisdictions originally reserved to the Sabah government are land, forest, agriculture, native law and customs, libraries, museums, local government, and water. They are hardly the hallmarks of a modern nation and advanced economy capable of governing and developing itself.

At the same time, most of the important legislative powers which would shape our own development, economy, well-being, unity, and social justice, are all controlled by the Federal Government (even originally under MA63 and now, under the Federal Constitution), such as: communications and transport (now 9th Schedule, Federal List, paragraph 10), education (now 9th Schedule, Federal List, paragraph 13), medicine and health (now 9th Schedule, Federal List, paragraph 14), labour and social security (now 9th Schedule, Federal List, paragraph 15), tourism (now 9th Schedule, Federal List, paragraph 25A).

Should any Sabahan in his right mind, satisfy with the minimalist state autonomy for Sabah on the one hand, and a dominant federal government (almost amounting to a unitary state in all but name) on the other hand? Or should we renegotiate for more state autonomy, not just confined with a limited framework the present Federal Constitution or even the MA63 only?

To do so meaningfully, such a discussion must involve a total reconsideration of Sabah’s place in the federation. In other words, it is time for a “New Federation” and a new kind of Federalism. That’s why we need New Deal.

What are the “new” elements in our Deal offered to Sabah?

Power Sharing – Deputy Prime Minister for Sabah and Sarawak to reflect the equal partner status for these two signatorites of MA63. Sabah should play a greater role in shaping her own as well as national policies. Limitation of Chief Minsiter tenure is important to prevent “absolute power corrupts absolutely”.

More state autonomies – To have Education, Health, Transport, Social Safety and Tourism under State List or Concurrent List. These are the important legislative powers which would shape our own development, economy, well-being, unity, and social justice, not solely controlled by Federal Government.

More revenue sharing – Fiscal decentralisation is the most important agenda for the whole exercise of devolution of power. Without resources, even the important legislative powers placed under State, we would concede them, when there is no sustainable finance resouces to maintain their admnistration. For example, Health was used to be Sabah’s own jurisdiction, but it was surrendered to federal in 1970, as Sabah was running dry of finance resources. The New Deal we offer to Sabah is, 20% Oil Royalty and 50% revenue sharing. This offer is definitely better than provisions 112C and 112D, Part V, Schedule 10, as enshrined in Federal Constitution.

The New Deal is not about personal agenda. It’s regardless whether Mahathir has wrongdoings in the past or is Lim Kit Siang is commited to the Sabah Special rights. It’s about Instituional Reform, and it’s our own Sabahan leaders in Pakatan Harapan to get the New Deal on board, in the event of Two Party system emerged in Malaysia.

New political landscape has provided a window of opportunity for Sabah, and we should exploit fully the opportunity to bargain for institutional reform which benefits the rakyat. While Raymond Tan has displayed a bad example to the people, he is just becoming defender for an embattled Prime Minister who is now desperate for supports.

A true concerned and committed Sabahan leader should fight for institutional reform, such as fiscal decentralisation, instead of apple-polishing a particular political leader who is trying to be a nice guy to Sabah. A blind loyalty to Putrajaya will only make Sabah a beggar in the Federation.

All right mindful Sabahan, let’s work hand in hand to deliver the New Deal to achieve the aspirations of the people! Don’t behave like Raymond.