This is my reply to what was raised by the MIC national treasurer, S Vell Paari a few days ago in his article ‘Does Pakatan have any plans for Indians‘ (Berita Daily, Sept 29, 2017).
Vell Paari thanked Lim Kit Siang and myself for taking the time off to reply to his earlier article in which he praised the Prime Minister Najib Razak as the “Father of Indian Development”.
He said that for both us to reply his article, it must have touched on “the nerves of the top echelons of the DAP”.
In the above article, he wanted Lim and myself to reply to the questions he had posed about whether Pakatan Harapan has any development plans for the Indian community, why we accepted the leadership of Dr Mahathir Mohamad in Pakatan without being emotional about it.
However, before he could hear from us, he himself said in his piece that Lim and myself are not in a position to answer his questions simply because “there are no answers”. In other words, he said that Pakatan has no programmes for Indians.
Vell Paari should not engage in the drama of self-importance as how he raised questions that no one has raised before. He should not overestimate his ability of posing questions and then childishly saying that Lim and myself would not have the answers as there are none in the first place.
As responsible elected representatives we had to counter the lies, half-truths and the embarrassing position taken by the MIC to engage in the senseless defence of Najib.
It is rather strange that even to this day, Vell Paari never had the objective mind to take his father, S Samy Vellu, former MIC president, for task for not doing anything worthwhile for the benefit of the Indian community.
Vell Paari can “go to town” in his praise of Najib, I don’t care. But if he drags the Indian community into his personal drama, then every Malaysian has the right of fair comment.
Vell Paari might think that Mahathir was one of the worst prime ministers Malaysia had. The Indian community suffered under his leadership tenure.
But at the same time, his father, Samy Vellu should shoulder part of the blame. What was the performance of Samy Vellu during his long years in the MIC? What development did he bring to uplift the poor Indian community?
I believe that the one the worst periods for the Indian community was when Mahathir was the prime minister and Samy Vellu was the leader of the MIC.
It was the combination of this deadly authoritarian leadership that caused havoc on the Indian community, majority of whom were worked in plantations and urban areas.
I would agree that if Vell Paari takes Mahathir to task for what he did and did not, but he should not spare his father, Samy Vellu for abandoning the welfare and well-being of the Indian community.
Just because Najib has given a governmental post to Samy Vellu does not render him as the great leader of the Indian community.
I would have grudgingly accepted if Vell Paari had called his father, Samy Vellu as the “Father of the Development of Indian community”.
While he is willing to bestow such a title on others, he lacks the elementary guts and decency to bestow on his own father, Samy Vellu. What a filial son? Maybe he thinks that his father doe not deserve such a title? Is it true?
If MIC leaders have no faith in their own party and leadership, then this does not augur well for the future of the party. As it is the party is in doldrums as Indians have gradually deserted its ranks.Umno might not be around too long to maintain its lifeline for the MIC.