Skip to content

Will Johor State Government be subject to the same degree of scrutiny like Penang State Government and if Johor State Government is prepared to be as open and transparent as Penang State Government when dealing with public outrage on the issue?

Around 1.8 million residents in Johor Baru, Kulai and Kota Tinggi have been affected by a major water supply disruption last Saturday, after operations at three water treatment plants were stopped due to high ammonia levels found in their raw water from the Johor River.

The million-dollar question is: will anyone be held responsible for the inconvenience caused by the major water supply disruption?

Yes, Johor State Government has directed a poultry farm and a factory that converts manure into fertiliser located along the Johor River to close down, after identifying the facilities as being responsible for pollution that disrupted water supply.

But that is far from sufficient.

According to Johor Health, Environment, Education and Information Committee chairman Ayub Rahmat, this was the third incident of ammonia pollution and based on Syarikat Air Johor (SAJ) investigation, it was caused by the same chicken droppings processing factory.

So my question is, what actions have been taken when the first and second incidents of ammonia pollution occurred?

Not only that, Ayub Rahmat also said that the Department of Environment (DOE) previously did not support the approval in the Preliminary Assessment Site (PAT) to proceed with the project in the area.

Penang Government was heavily criticized for approving Tanjung Bungah affordable housing project despite DOE’s disapproval. Penang State Government has explained that it was because it received the approval from the Department of Minerals and Geoscience (DMG), the agency responsible for mining activities as well as slope and soil stability and DOE has no objection to the Tunku Abdul Rahman College project, which located adjacent to the accident site and just as close if not nearer to the quarry in question.

So now, can Johor State Government be as transparent as Penang State Government and provide reasons why the project was allowed despite DOE’s disapproval?

In a report by the New Straits Times (NST), director for Johor’s DOE Mohammad Ezanni Mat Salleh said based on checks conducted by DOE staff at the farm since the previous case of pollution last year, the factory did not adhere to proper storage techniques for its fertiliser.

Whose responsibility is it to ensure that the factory adhere to the requirements imposed? And why operating licence was issued or the factory was allowed to operate before it adhered to all technical requirements?

Kulai District Land Administrative Office issued a 7A notice for violating terms under Section 129 of the National Land Code to the owner in September last year, two months after the previous big case of ammonia pollution in July last year, for violating its land usage terms under the National Land Code 1965. The notice required the owner to return to the original terms for land use.

Kulai District Officer Md Za’nal Misran said after the first notice was issued, investigations were carried out, and Kulai District Land Administrative Office countinued to monitor the premises, but the owner did not adhere to it.

However, Kulai District Land Administrative Office waited till September this year, to issue its second notice known as 7B under Section 129 of the National Land Code 1965, which is a showcause notice that required the owner to give his reason why he did not revert to the original terms of the land usage.

Why does it take so long to issue the 2nd notice to the operators? Looking at the limited information available now, can we not say the water supply disruption could have been avoided if the state government had adhered to the advice of the relevant agencies and prevailing rules and guidelines?

In Penang, an Exco was detained by MACC in illegal factory probe. My question to Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment, MACC and all Federal Government Agencies is, will Johor State Government also be subject to the same degree of scrutiny like Penang State Government and if Johor State Government is prepared to be as open and transparent as Penang State Government when dealing with public outrage on the issue?