The mainstream thinking of Barisan Nasional leaders that Sabah and Sarawak are just like any other states in Malaysia is clearly reflected in Dewan Rakyat Speaker Tan Sri Pandikar Amin Mulia’s public lecture on the 1963 Malaysia Agreement (MA63) last weekend.
Among Pandikar’s key points on issues related to the MA63 which was widely publicised in the media today included Sabah and Sarawak were never two separate nations, but only British colonies, prior to the formation of Malaysia.
Pandikar also contended that Sabah has never been downgraded to being a state in Malaysia, from being one of three equal partners (along with Sarawak and Malaya) because Sabah and Sarawak were already at the same level as the other states and not (with) the Federation (of Malaya).
Pandikar also described claims by certain quarters that Sabah’s rights were not fully executed under the 1963 Malaysia Agreement (MA63) as empty political rhetoric to incite anger and hatred among the people in Sabah.
However, DAP Sabah disagreed with Pandikar and his interpretations on the subject matter.
First and foremost, even if Sabah and Sarawak were not nations prior formation of Malaysia, but both territotires were the signatories to MA63.
“We were the founding members to this federation, and not just one of the states in the federation. Without Sabah and Sarawak, there is no Malaysia.
The 1976 amendment on Article 1(2) of Federal Constitution have significant implications on the status of Sabah and Sarawak.
Changes in the wordings from three categories of states in Malaysia (States of Malaya, Borneo States, and Singapore) to one catch-all sentence (Malaysia consists of the states with their respective name), had reflected the “no difference” among all the states.
The historical fact that Sabah and Sarawak were founding partners of this federation, has been deleted from the memory of the ruling party leaders.
Sabah and Sarawak are never “just one of the states” in the federation. Malaysia is an example of asymmetrical design of Federalism, with these two territories have more autonomies which are safeguarded by the constitutional arrangement as enshrined in not only Federal Constitution, but also MA63 and Inter-Governmental Committee (IGC) Report.
We have special provisions in immigration control, education, religious matters, natives protection and financial powers.
How could Pandikar said we have no special positions and priviledges over other Malayan states?
It was totally wrong for Pandikar to label all the claims of “Sabah’s rights are not fully excetud under MA63” as empty political rhetorics.
There are so many examples in which Federal government has violated the MA63 and Federal Constitution and I will just name two major issues here namely the Special grant of 40 per cent net revenue generated from Sabah to Federal government should be returned to the state, as provided by Article 112C and 112D of the Federal Constitution.
It is most disappointing to note that after the first review in 1969, where the amounts for the subsequent five years were determined, there has not been any further review. The amount of annual special grant for Sabah stays at RM26.7 million since 1974 until today, thus in breach of the Federal Constitution.
The second issue was in reference to Article 2 of the Federal Constitution, which has stipulated that the Parliament may by law alter the boundaries to any State but a law altering the boundaries shall not be passed without the consent of that state in a state legislature.
However the enactment of the Territorial Sea Act 2012 (and its predecessor, the Continental Shelf Act 1969) has the effect of usurping the territories of Sabah and Sarawak.
And no law relating to this was passed in the Sabah and Sarawak state assembly to effect the altering of the boundary, thus it is in clear violation of the Federal Constitution.
I wonder why should Pandikar Amin being a leader from Sabah choose to play an unpopular role in defending all the undefendable wrongdoings by the BN Federal government.
Pandikar’s public lecture mirrored the mainstream thinking of BN leaders. They are seriously infected with the Syndrome of Denial, and could not allow Sabah and Sarawak to be different with other states.